We use cookies to help our website function properly, understand how visitors use our site, and improve your experience. You can choose which optional cookies you allow. Read More
juliannkillian
About juliannkillian
How interim CFOs help ad agencies in New York City: retainers
Knowing how interim CFOs help ad agencies in New York City starts with one question: what work stops when the finance lead walks out? Usually it is the weekly cash view, the invoice follow-up, the payroll check and the numbers the owner reads before deciding whom to hire. An interim CFO takes over those tasks for a set period, often under a monthly retainer. The retainer buys continuity, not a promised outcome, so the agreement has to name the work.
What an interim CFO does in the first weeks
Start with the gap itself. When a CFO leaves, the work does not stop. It piles up. Bills still need to go out, payroll still has to run, and the bank still asks for statements. An interim CFO’s first job is to find out which of these tasks are moving and which ones depend on one person’s memory. That inventory is the first document you should ask for in writing.
In the early weeks, a competent interim CFO spends most of the time on cash. They reconcile the bank accounts with the books, list what clients owe the agency and what the agency owes its vendors, interim CFO startup in New York City and build a short cash forecast for the next few months. For an agency, receivables often matter more than the profit line. Client payments can arrive late, and staff costs do not wait.
Ask the candidate what they will do in week one. A good answer names files, systems and meetings. A bad one is a slogan, such as ”we will fix your cash flow.” Ask whether they will review the chart of accounts, the billing schedule and the approval process for vendor payments. If the answer stays vague, the proposal is not ready, no matter how confident the pitch sounds.
The second phase usually covers reporting. The interim lead decides what the owner needs each month, sets a close date and asks the bookkeeper or outside accountant to follow it. Many agencies get monthly numbers weeks after the month ends, which means hiring and media spend get decided on old data. A realistic goal is a close that is on time and consistent. A perfect close in the first month is not a realistic goal.
The agency also needs someone who can speak to the bank, the landlord and the payroll provider with real authority. An interim CFO can take those calls, but they should not sign anything beyond the authority the owner has written down. Ask what that document says about signing rights and who approves payments above a set amount. Keep a copy in your own files, not only in the consultant’s.
Where interim, fractional, controller and outsourced accounting differ
The labels overlap, and sellers use them loosely. Each one describes a different job, so read the scope, not the title. A firm can call its person an interim CFO and then deliver only bookkeeping. The reverse also happens.
An interim CFO fills a seat. They act as the finance executive for a period, usually full-time or close to it, and they carry the authority of the role while the company searches for a permanent hire. A fractional CFO works part-time, often on a standing schedule, and tends to advise more than run daily operations. Neither title guarantees what the other does.
A controller owns the accounting function: the close, the general ledger, the controls over transactions and often the staff who record them. Outsourced accounting is a service that handles tasks such as bookkeeping, payroll processing and month-end entries for a fee, usually without making strategic calls. Bookkeeping is the narrowest of the four. Here is how they compare on the points that matter most to an agency owner.
| Attribute | Interim CFO | Fractional CFO | Controller | Outsourced accounting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Typical role | Acting finance executive during a gap | Part-time strategic finance adviser | Manages the close and accounting staff | Performs recurring accounting tasks |
| Who makes final calls | The interim CFO, within the owner’s written authority | The owner, with advice | The owner or CFO | The owner |
| Usual deliverables | Cash forecast, close, reporting, handoff memo | Forecast reviews, board or lender packages, planning | Monthly close, ledger, transaction controls | Bookkeeping, payroll entries, reconciliations |
| Best fit | A CFO gap or a transition under pressure | Growth decisions without a full-time executive | Broken or late close with no one owning it | Routine work with no strategic need |
The table is a starting point, not a verdict. An agency with a broken close and no one to read the numbers may need a controller more than a CFO. An agency with clean books but no plan for a bank line may need strategic finance, which is usually a fractional job. Match the role to the gap you have, not to the name the firm prefers.
Ask who will sign off on your financial statements, who decides how and when revenue is recorded and who will sit in the room with your lender. The answers show whether the person is a manager, an adviser or a vendor. Get those answers in writing, because a title on a business card can cover any of the three.
What a retainer covers and what it leaves out
Retainers are common in this kind of work, and the model is not wrong in itself. A retainer is a standing fee for access to a defined amount of work, usually billed on a regular schedule. The problem is an agreement that does not say what the monthly fee buys. A retainer with a vague scope is a blank check with a friendly name.
Read the scope section first. It should list recurring tasks, such as weekly cash reporting, a monthly close review, forecast updates and a set number of meetings with the owner. It should also list what is outside the scope, such as fundraising decks, audit support, system migrations or tax filings. If a task is not named, assume it costs extra. What does that actually cover? If the answer is ”general financial support,” the contract is not finished.
Ask what happens when the work goes beyond the scope. Some firms bill hourly for extras, while others require a written change order before any extra work starts. Neither approach is wrong, but you need the rule before the first surprise invoice arrives. Also ask whether the retainer includes a named person or a rotating team, because that changes who you can call on a bad day.
Termination terms matter as much as the monthly fee. Check the notice period, what happens to files and system access when the engagement ends, and whether the firm keeps its working papers or hands them over. A useful test: if you end the contract tomorrow, can your own staff find the cash forecast, the bank reconciliations and the close checklist? If not, the agreement is building dependence instead of capability.
Be careful with claims inside the proposal. Language about better margins, faster fundraising or a higher sale price describes a result, and no firm can guarantee one. Ask the firm to remove those lines or replace them with the activities it will perform. Activities are something you can check each week. Results depend on many things the firm does not control, including your clients, your market and your lenders.
Cash visibility and forecasting after the finance lead leaves
Cash is usually the first problem an agency notices after a CFO leaves. Money comes in on client payment schedules and goes out on payroll, rent, contractors and media vendors. Without someone tracking both sides, the owner learns about a shortfall when a payment fails. An interim lead builds a view that shows the next several weeks clearly, so the owner can act before that happens.
A basic forecast for an agency starts with receivables by client and due date, then adds payroll, contractor payments, rent, software subscriptions and taxes. Each line needs a source. Pulling numbers from the accounting system is better than estimating from memory. If you already use QuickBooks, NetSuite or Sage Intacct, make that system the source of record and export the data in a form you can check line by line.
Agencies face a timing problem. Retainer billing can run ahead of the work delivered, while project fees may be billed only after a milestone is approved. That difference changes how cash looks from one month to the next. Ask how the forecast treats advance payments and what it assumes about late payers. A forecast that assumes every client pays on time is a hopeful document, not a plan.
Expect the forecast to be imperfect. The aim is a weekly update that the owner trusts enough to make hiring and spending decisions. An interim CFO who can show how the forecast changed last month, and why, is giving you something real. One who presents a single smooth chart with no explanation of its assumptions is not.
Keep the assumptions in writing. Note the top three risks, such as one large client that pays slowly or a vendor that expects payment in advance, and write down the actions you will take if cash falls below a level the owner sets. Those notes outlast the interim engagement and give the next finance lead something to start from.
Clean books for lenders, investors and buyers
Lenders and investors read financial records differently from the owner. They want consistent reports, a close that happens on schedule and an explanation for any unusual entry. Agencies often arrive at a fundraise or a loan application with a backlog of unreconciled accounts. That backlog takes time to clear, and it makes the numbers harder to defend when someone asks hard questions.
Revenue recognition is a common trouble spot. ASC 606 sets out how revenue is recognized when a contract includes performance obligations, and that guidance matters for agencies. The practical questions include how to handle retainer fees, bonuses tied to campaign results and work billed before delivery. Ask your interim CFO to document the policy and apply it the same way every month. Consistency matters more than a clever policy that changes with each quarter.
Internal controls are dull, but they protect the company. Basic examples include separating the person who approves a vendor bill from the person who pays it, requiring a second approval above a set amount and reviewing bank access each quarter. Ask the candidate which controls they will put in place in the first weeks and which ones they will leave for a permanent hire to own.
Systems matter too. Many small agencies run on a mix of spreadsheets and a basic accounting package. An interim CFO can recommend changes, but moving to a new system during a transition adds risk. Ask whether the firm will migrate the data, who will test the new setup and what happens to the old records. If the answer is ”we will handle it,” ask what that means in concrete steps and who signs off on each one.
Due diligence requests usually arrive as a list. Ask the interim CFO to prepare the core files: monthly statements for the period requested, the reconciliations behind them, the revenue policy, the contract list and a summary of ownership. Preparation does not promise a deal. It only means the questions get answered faster, which can matter when a buyer or lender has limited patience and a short timeline.
Handing off to a permanent CFO without losing the thread
Many agencies hire an interim CFO expecting a permanent hire to follow. The handoff is where value is either kept or lost. A permanent CFO who arrives to a folder of unexplained entries and no written forecast starts from zero, and that costs time and trust with the team and the bank alike.
Plan the handoff from the first week. The interim lead should keep a running log of decisions, open items and the reasons behind them. That log should include the close calendar, the list of recurring entries, the payment approvals and the forecast model with its assumptions. A short written handoff memo is more useful than a long meeting that nobody takes notes in.
Ask the interim CFO to work alongside the candidate during interviews and in the first weeks of the new hire’s tenure. Watching a monthly close is more useful than reading a document about one. If the interim lead refuses to overlap with the new hire, ask why, and write down the answer, because that refusal tells you something about how the handoff will go.
The owner also needs to decide what the permanent CFO owns that the interim did not. Some agencies keep certain tasks with the controller or an outside accountant. Define those lines before the new hire starts. Otherwise two people will keep the same spreadsheet, and neither will know which version is current when the bank asks for it.
Keep the end date and the handoff steps in the agreement. When the engagement ends, ask for a final review, a list of open items and an orderly removal of system access. A clean exit is one of the few things you can check directly, so check it before the last invoice is paid.
Red flags and common mistakes when you compare proposals
Use this checklist when you compare firms. Each item is a question you can answer with a document, not a feeling. A single red flag does not disqualify a firm, but several together should slow you down and push you to ask for more detail in writing.
- The proposal promises a fix to cash flow, Venture Growth Partners Capital structure or a sale price but does not list the work behind the promise.
- The scope names no deliverables, only phrases such as ”strategic guidance” or ”full financial support.”
- The firm will not name the person who will do the work, or the person you meet is not the one who signs the contract.
- The proposal relies on biographies or client stories you cannot check against your own company’s size and industry.
- The retainer has no notice period, no exit terms and no rule for extra work.
- The firm asks to take over bank access or payment approvals before your own signing rules are written down.
Buyers make predictable mistakes too. Owners often hire on the first call because they feel pressure to act. They skip the reference check or accept references only from a list the firm chose. They also assume an interim lead will repair a broken process on their own. Usually the owner has to make the decisions and provide access, and the interim lead can only work with what they are given.
Another mistake is treating the retainer as a replacement for internal knowledge. If no one at the agency can read the forecast, the engagement is fragile. Ask for a short working session in which your own team walks through the numbers with the interim lead. Even an hour a week for a while is worth the time, because it keeps the knowledge inside the company.
Do not accept the first proposal as the market price for the work. Ask for two or three written scopes for the same work and compare them line by line. The differences in what is included matter more than the monthly fee. A cheap retainer that leaves out the close is not cheap, because you will pay for the missing work somewhere else.
Finally, check the claims about experience. Ask what work the person has done for companies of your size and industry, and what they would decline to take on. A firm that says it does everything for everyone is describing a pitch, not a practice. Ask for specifics you can verify, and treat anything you cannot verify as unknown until someone shows you the evidence.
When an interim CFO is worth it and when it is not
An interim CFO is worth considering when a finance gap threatens decisions you must make soon. Examples include a CFO who left in the middle of a bank negotiation, an owner who cannot see the cash position in a given week and a fundraising round that needs clean statements within a limited window. In those cases, continuity usually matters more than the cost of the role.
It is less useful when the problem is small and specific. If you need one-off tax preparation, a clean payroll setup or a single month of catch-up bookkeeping, an outsourced accountant or a bookkeeper may cover the need with a narrower scope. Paying for a full interim role to do a narrow job rarely makes sense, and the mismatch often shows up as frustration on both sides.
It is also a poor fit when the owner does not want to change how decisions get made. An interim CFO can build reports and recommend controls, but they cannot force an owner to follow a payment schedule or stop approving spending by text message. If the business runs on verbal approvals and last-minute transfers, the work will keep breaking, and the retainer will feel like it is not working.
Timing matters as well. A search for a permanent CFO can take a long time, and an interim lead bridges that gap. If you already have a capable controller and a plan for the search, you may need strategic help for only a few weeks. That points to a fractional engagement with a narrower scope, not a full interim role.
The honest answer for many agencies is a mix of roles. A controller keeps the books clean, an outside accountant handles routine entries, and an interim or fractional lead sets the forecast and the reporting. Write down which of these roles you need and which you do not before you talk to anyone about a retainer. That list will shape the proposal you ask for and interim CFO startup in New York City the comparisons you make.
A decision test to apply before you sign a retainer
Before you sign, apply one test: can you describe the first four weeks of work in your own words, and could your team check whether that work happened? If the answer is no, the proposal is not specific enough. This test works no matter how strong the firm’s reputation sounds or how polished the pitch looks.
Next, write down the three decisions the interim lead must support. For example, you might need to decide whether to delay a hire, whether to accept a client’s slower payment terms or whether to approach a lender this quarter. If the scope does not help with those decisions, it is the wrong engagement, even if the firm is competent at other work.
Ask for the deliverables in writing: a weekly cash update, a monthly close with a set date, a forecast with stated assumptions, a list of open items and a handoff memo. Each deliverable should have an owner and a date. A deliverable without a date is a wish, and a wish is hard to hold anyone to when the bank calls.
![]()
Check the exit before you start. Confirm how the agreement ends, who keeps the files and how system access is removed. A retainer that is easy to leave is one you can afford to test. A retainer that holds your records hostage is a bad trade, even if the day-to-day work is good, because you lose the ability to switch when you need to.
Last, ask what the engagement will not do. A clear list of exclusions protects you from surprise invoices and from false expectations about results. If the firm cannot name what it will not do, it has not thought through its own scope. Do not sign until it has, and keep the exclusions list with the contract where your team can find it.
No listing found.